Gateway by Frederik Pohl
Hello, Stranger.
Primary Driver: (Plot, World, or Character)
Bechdel Test: Pass
Technobabble: Low-Moderate.
Review: Really good. Cleverly bounces between the story as it unfolds and therapy sessions afterwards - we know that our hero survives, but something terrible has happened. A bit too Freudian. Still, excellent job of making a complex protagonist, interesting world, compelling story. Wanting to know what went wrong kept me reading - and it pays off.
"Are you satisfied, Robbie?""What?""Have you established to your own satisfaction that I am only a machine? That you can control me at any time?"I stop short. "Is that what I'm doing?" I demand, surprised. And then, "All right, I guess so. You're a machine, Sigfrid. I can control you."And he says after me as I leave, "We always knew that, really, didn't we? The real thing you fear — the place where you feel control is needed — isn't that in you?"
The codes in his pocket have been built up through multiple sessions before this one. We don't quite know what they are, but have some vague ideas. Their use doesn't give Bob the control he wants; instead we see how desperate he is to have power over something. He's lost.
Bob's issues, let us turn to one of the more upsetting moments in this story.
I reached out to touch her, and she sobbed and hit me, as hard as she could. The blow caught me on the shoulder.That was a mistake.That's always a mistake. It isn't a matter of what's rational or justified, it is a matter of signals. It was the wrong signal to give me. The reason wolves don't kill each other off is that the smaller and weaker wolf always surrenders. It rolls over, bares its throat and puts its paws in the air to signal that it is beaten. When that happens the winner is physically unable to attack anymore. If it were not that way, there wouldn't be any wolves left. For the same reason men don't usually kill women, or not by beating them to death. They can't. However much he wants to hit her, his internal machinery vetoes it. But if the woman makes the mistake of giving him a different signal by hitting him first— I punched her four or five times, as hard as I could, on the breast, in the face, in the belly. She fell to the ground, sobbing. I knelt beside her, lifted her up with one hand and, in absolutely cold blood, slapped her twice more. It was all happening as if choreographed by God, absolutely inevitably; and at the same I could feel that I was breathing as hard as though I'd climbed a mountain on a dead run. The blood was thundering in my ears. Everything I saw was hazed with red.
This is awful both in and out of context. What context clarifies is that the justifications and rationalizing are Bob's ideas, as opposed to the authors. He takes as little responsibility as he can, blaming society and instinct, taking a step away from himself to make it a general issue. We see exactly the same in his therapy sessions, and it is brought to our attention a number of times by Sigfrid. It is an excellent character moment - he is the only one to blame for his choices, despite his protestations. He regrets it almost immediately afterwards; if he didn't, we would think he was a sociopath. But regret is not enough.
He sees Klara again before the end, but only briefly, and never enough to atone for what he did. She pushes him away.
The climax of this book is a banger, and it comes right at the end. Everything comes to a head beautifully. He and Klara, as well as eight other people, two ships of five, get stuck at the edge of a black hole. Ultimately he is the only one who escapes, blasting one ship off the other, pushing his friends and the woman he loves deeper in, further into time dilation. Or maybe it was not him who pressed the button; he does not know, but he blames himself.
"But Rob," he says reasonably, "we've been all over this. They're still alive; they all are. Time has stopped for them—"
"I know," I howl. "Don't you understand, Sigfrid? That's the point. I not only killed her, I'm still killing her!"
Patiently: "Do you think what you just said is true, Rob?"
"She thinks it is! Now, and forever, as long as I live. It's not years ago that it happened for her. It's only a few minutes, and it goes on for all of my life. I'm down here, getting older, trying to forget, and there's Klara up there in Sagittarius YY, floating around like a fly in amber!"
What an excellent book. And what a haunting end.
Just drop me off by the next black hole, Stranger.And don't forget to read a book!
Comments
Post a Comment